The Tipple website uses essential cookies to make it work. We'd also like to use analytics cookies to understand how people use the site and improve it. Analytics cookies are only set if you accept. Posts from X, Instagram, TikTok and YouTube shown on the site can set their own cookies. For more detail, see our Privacy Policy.
You can change your choice at any time with Cookie settings at the bottom of every page.
My League One Predictions Revisited: What I Got Wrong · Tipple
If you thought I was wrong about the Championship, you haven’t seen anything yet.
Predictions Revisit
Part Two: League One
Listen, everyone knows League One is a notoriously hard league to predict. The fact I’m having to open with that should be an indication as to just how wrong I got it when I made my predictions before a ball was kicked.
I’m not particularly proud of any of my selections here, but there’s one in particular that might just be my worst punt of all time. So that’s something to look forward to!
Right, let’s get this over with. Here are my pre-season League One predictions, and what I’d change them to given the chance.
🏆 Title Winners
Predicted: Luton Town
At face value, my title winners being in fourth place and just five points from the top at this early stage doesn’t seem too bad. What was I worrying about? The on-pitch reality, however, paints a different picture.
I’m of the belief that, even this early in the season, there are only two clear standout teams that can win the title. Huddersfield and Stockport. I just can’t bring myself to throw Luton’s hat into the ring.
Jack Wilshere’s team have issues in both boxes, and probably my favourite midfield in the league holding them together. Defensively they’re a shambles, conceding goals and chances at a rate commensurate with that of team battling to stave off the drop, and they’re uninspiring at best going forwards. They have a lot of players capable of scoring some goals, but who in that team is going to score loads? Nahki Wells has chipped in with 7 so far, but relying on a 36 year old to stay fit and keep up is risky at best. Outside of him they look middling-to-poor in the striking department, relying instead on their talented group of wide players and midfielders to chip in with the goals.
Don’t get me wrong, I like a lot of their players and I think they have the best midfield three in the division, but I’m not sure they’re anywhere near my title winners. Luton Town: a good team, not a great one.
Revised Prediction: Huddersfield Town
I have three words for you. Derensili. Sanches. Fernandes.
What a player Huddersfield have on their hands there. Outside of Fernandes, they’re an incredibly well-drilled team under Martin Drury with the strongest attack, third best defence and a clear identity and style in the way they approach games. And in Fernandes they have the outright best player in the division to go atop their strong foundations. Coupled with that the reemergence of Joe Taylor as the premier goal threat in the division, and you have a serious team on your hands.
Exceptionally well coached with the league’s best finisher up top and the league’s best player buzzing around him. What’s not to love, Terriers fans?
Enjoyed it? Give it a like and send it to your mates.
Let’s just hope they can keep hold of Taylor, Fernandes, and Drury for the remainder of the season…
⬆️ Promoted Sides
Prediction: Leicester, Plymouth Argyle
If the last one was an excusable, but ultimately incorrect, prediction, this is the start of the really bad shouts. If anything, Leicester to be promoted isn’t even in my top three worst picks from my League One preview. It’s that good.
What I will say is this: despite their well-documented shortcomings, I do think the sheer quality of Leicester’s playing squad could see them climb up the division as the weeks start to tick by. Russell Martin is also notorious for having tricky settling in periods before putting together long stretches of immaculate form that see his sides finish strongly. I’m not completely divorcing myself from this prediction just yet. That being said, if I got placed in a coma tomorrow and woke up after the season close date (I’d be gutted I’d missed the final day, by the way) and you showed me the League One table I wouldn’t be surprised to see Leicester in position between 2nd and 23rd. I can just as easily envision it all crumbling down as I can it all falling into place and them putting together a season-saving run. Maybe that means they’re just average. Certainly not nailed-on promotion contenders like I’d predicted.
Argyle’s late surge last season swayed me to back them this time around and, while there have been some incredibly high highs, I think the lows are too low to ignore. They see very little of the ball, concede a lot of chances and don’t create enough to offset their leaky defence. They’re up in 6th at the moment, and I think it’s much more likely they slip down the table than suddenly hit form and stick around the top end. I’ve also unsuccessfully backed them five times in my Tipple picks this season, so I’ve not got a lot of time for those boys in green these days.
Revised Prediction: Stockport County, MK Dons
Stockport and Huddersfield are my top two. They’ve been miles above the rest of the division in terms of their performance levels so far, and the results have reflected that dominance. Unfortunately, I’ll have a lot more to say about Stockport in the next section. As I said, these were bad predictions.
The final promotion spot is a tricky one for me to work out, mostly because all of the eligible sides have glaring weaknesses to their game that put me off backing them. Still, it has to be someone. I considered Oxford, but think the lack of squad depth and experience with eventually catch up with them once the busy high-intensity period starts to heat up. Reading are the most fun to watch but blow too hot and cold to put together a serious run at promotion for me. I like Luton and Argyle but their defensive issues worry me too much. Sheffield Wednesday could creep in there, and they’ll definitely wind up in the top six, but again I think the squad is too thin to maybe go all the way. I don’t know why I’m stalling, you’ve seen it at the top. After 7 wins from 8 in all competitions, I’m putting all my eggs in the MK Dons basket
More accurately, all of my eggs are going in the Paul Warne basket. In a league with so many nearly good teams, those with the best coaches tend to rise to the top. When the going gets tough and it gets down to the nitty gritty, Paul Warne teams just get results. I’ve seen it with my own two eyes when he managed Derby. While our rivals were feeling the late-season pressure and dropping silly points against mid-table sides, Warne’s team turned up every weekend and saw out a routine 1-0 win like it was the easiest thing in the world. Do I think this MK Dons team are amazing? No. Would I be happy seeing them promoted? Also no. But do I think that, amongst a sea of okay teams, Paul Warne has what it takes to guide his above the rest and achieve yet another League One promotion? Absolutely.
😔 Underachievers
Prediction: Stockport
Steady. This isn’t even the worst one.
Quite frankly, I gave Dave Challinor too much credit. I thought his departure would spell the beginning of an uncomfortable transitional period for the Hatters that would see them settle into mid-table obscurity for a season or two while they looked for a new identity in his wake. The reality is that Jim McNulty has strolled straight in and made them even better than they were before.
I can’t even be annoyed at myself, they’re just so good to watch. They play possession-heavy football whilst still proving that that doesn’t have to mean boring sideways rubbish. The two 10s in behind Kyle Wootton cause chaos in the opposition box, with big Oliver Norwood still pulling the strings from the base of midfield and able to unpick the more difficult defences. McNulty’s wing “backs” are more like traditional wide players, pushing high and stretching the opposition while the wide centre/halves fill in behind them. The whole systems works so fluidly and the players execute McNulty’s wishes so fluently you almost forget he’s only been there since the summer, it’s remarkable. Will they underachieve? I don’t think so, no.
Revised Prediction: Blackpool
Relative to their budget, the Tangerine Army just haven’t been good enough this season. They’ve had the odd result here or there, but their general level of performance has been shockingly poor, and I think they’ll only stay in the division on the back of four teams managing to be even worse than them.
Ian Evatt looks completely out of his depth, none of their big-name players are performing, and they’re relying on a notoriously shaky goalie in Bailey Peacock-Farrell to bail them out of most situations. He’s been fantastic so far, but if his career is anything to go by then that run won’t last.
Blackpool have the playing budget of a team that should be pushing for promotion, and they’ve spent it on a group of players that look like they’d struggle to look capable in the division below. Dark times once again at Bloomfield Road.
🐴 Dark Horses
Prediction: Barnsley
Right, this is the bad one. I honestly cannot tell you what I might have been thinking.
The only excuse I can come up with is that I was, at the time, taking a copious amount of mind-altering substances and I have now been admitted to rehab and am proud to say I can see clearly once again. It’s either that or I was kicked in the head by a horse.
The even sadder reality is that I probably just listened to Callum Fowler too intently. Maybe I fell asleep with his podcast on and his opinions infested by subconscious. I really don’t know how I can even justify this. I feel the need to present a passage from my pre-season predictions so you can really get into my psyche at the time. I’m doing this with energy of a man attempting to plead insanity to get a lesser sentence for murdering his family.
“Admittedly their squad has some gaping holes that need plugging, but they have the makings of a real talented bunch if Stendel can get the formula right. It might all crash and burn, but you can guarantee that under the new coaching staff it will at least be full-throttle entertainment.”
Gaping holes. Crash and burn. I had it all right in front of me. Of course that was going to happen, this squad is absolutely dreadful! I cannot comprehend how I allowed myself to think that the mere presence of a manager who was once good at Barnsley 8 years ago would be enough to send this bunch on a play-off charge.
There’s no excusing it. It is what it is. Barnsley are not only not on a play-off charge, they’re almost certainly going down as one of the weakest League One teams we’ve seen in years.
Revised Prediction: Oxford United
I found this one massively difficult.
Despite being newly promoted, MK Dons’ budget excludes them from being true dark horses. I honestly believe Cambridge will drop off, even though they’ve had a fantastic start for a promoted side, and Reading finished basically just outsides the play-offs last year, as well as the year before, so they’re no big surprise either.
Reluctantly, I’ve gone for Oxford here as they have performed well above the level many (me) had them pegged for with their patchwork squad of freebies and children, but I don’t think a relegated side challenging for the play-offs can ever really be considered a proper dark horse.
Aaron Ramsey has his cobbled-together squad performing remarkably well, with their only loss of the season coming away from home at a Huddersfield side that are fairly universally accepted to be the best team in the league. With the transfer embargo likely to be lifted in January, this Oxford team that many had down to be battling to survive might just sneak into the automatic promotion places. Whatever they end up doing, I just hope we get to see as much of Mo Missanga as physically possible. I love when a club facing adversity has to turn to it’s academy and they unearth a proper gem. Some lads have just got it and some don’t, and he has it in buckets.
⬇️ Relegated
Prediction: Burton, Bromley, AFC Wimbledon, Cambridge
Ouch, nice, eh, OUCH. In that order.
I’ll start with the Brewers. Gary Bowyer will not let this team get relegated. It’s absurd. Granted, it’s still early days, but this latest iteration of Burton look like the most standard lower-mid table side you could possibly imagine. Bowyer’s work has been some of the best across the EFL in recent years, its essentially a miracle that a team of their financial capabilities is able to operate at this level without embarrassing itself, never mind survive comfortably and take a few scalps along the way!
Bromley! I got one right! Andy Woodman has made way after their disastrous displays to start the season, but it’s not really the gaffer’s fault. Well, it sort of is. If he hadn’t been so selfish and gotten them promoted too early then they might have had a better settled squad to deal with the jump up… Bromley look like far and away the worst side in the league, and maybe the most out-of-their-depth EFL team we’ve seen in years. Sad, but inevitable.
Wimbledon could still go. They’re in a similar situation to Burton. No money, great gaffer. It’s only a matter of time before their financial incapabilities catch up to them, but Johnnie Jackson is doing more than enough to keep them competitive in the division in the meantime. The long fixture list may eventually swallow them whole, but I believe they’ll stay up over the top of four teams that are just much worse than Wimbledon. It’s as simple as that.
Cambridge is a stinker. As mentioned above, they’re having a barnstorming start to the season. Neil Harris has done a brilliant job, while also providing us with some press-conference gold, and they just look like a really good team. You can’t ask for much more than that as a promoted side. Comfortable mid-table bliss. I’d kill for some of that right now.
I’ve searched my brain and my heart for the answers, and they both returned the same answer every time. The current bottom four will be the four that go. I know, I know, it seems to easy. The lazy pick almost. But that’s what they want you to think. Sky want you to believe that there’s going to be drama right to the very last kick of the season to sell you more subscriptions, but the League One relegation battle is all-but over.
In actuality I see it as more of a 3+1 situation. Bromley, Barnsley, and Peterborough are done for. The former two for the reasons mentioned previously, and Posh because they’ve systematically weakened their squad through years of selling without reinvestment and then gone and hired a glorified clown to manage them because he’s a “good bloke”. It’s not the strategy I would’ve gone for.
That leaves one spot open for another team to enjoy a trip down to the fourth tier, and the race is tight between them. Wigan look basically rubbish but have proven themselves capable of beating the teams around them when it really matters. Blackpool look even worse but have the playing squad to get themselves to safety should they do the right thing and push Ian Evatt off the end of the pier and get a proper manager in. Notts County and Wimbledon have poor squads but are spearheaded by managers that know what they’re doing and have a defined identity for their sides which will see them do just enough to survive. That just leaves Donny.
Their three wins have come against Peterborough, who are rubbish, Burton, who are rubbish when they fancy it, and Sheffield Wednesday under Pedersen, who were also rubbish most weeks. Those games aside, they’ve basically been turned over every Saturday and Tuesday since the season kicked off. They don’t really score a lot, they don’t stop many going in, and they do very little with the ball when they actually manage to get hold of it. Greater than all of that, the atmosphere around the club just feels horrible. When you get a big club like Donny that are expected to kick on and things go south, the ire of the fanbase gets out of hand quickly. It was palpable in their embarrassing 3-0 defeat to non-league Kidderminster in the FA Cup, and they have Bradford, Huddersfield and Reading up to face them next. It could get really nasty, really fast.
So, there you have it. I might be number one globally on the Tipple Sports leaderboard (I’m never going to stop bringing that up until it’s no longer true) but it turns out I don’t know everything! Just League Two to go now… it can’t be as bad as this, can it?
Comments
Have your say. Sign in to comment.
No comments yet. Be the first.